Шип Надія Андріївна - Слов’янофільський проект розв’язання "польського питання" в Російській імперії (початок ХХ ст.) (2018)

  ARCHIVE (All issues) /     Content (2018, Issue 22)Ukrainian English

Shyp Nadiia Andriivna

Slavophil project for solving the "Polish question" in the Russian Empire (early 20th century)

Section: Studies in Special Historical Disciplines

Abstract: The actuality of studying the ideology of late Slavophilism is dictated by the need for a historiosophic understanding of interethnic relations in the Slavic world at the beginning of the 20th century, since the current confrontation between the two Slavic countries – Russia and Ukraine – in the territory of Donbas confi rms the concept of a spiral development of history that tends to repeat in a modified form. Thematically, Slavophilism has been studied quite fully, but in modern historiography there is no comprehensive analysis of the attitude of the Slavophiles to the “Polish question”. The early 20th century, in accordance with the new socio-economic and political situation in the Russian Empire, compared with the previous period, marked the organizational design of Neo-Slavism – the direction of public thought of a bourgeois-democratic orientation. At the same time, a partial modernization of the Slavophile ideology takes place, taking into account new realities, including international ones. Neo-Slavs and Neo-Slavophiles had a common desire to develop the principles of a new Slavic worldview, based on ethno-cultural reciprocity, but different forms of its manifestation. One of the outstanding representatives of neo-Slavophilism is the scientist economist, public figure, publicist S. Sharapov. He prepared materials for the All-Slavic Congress in Russia. His draft resolution of the Polish question contained a considerable amount of rational grain. Remaining a convinced adherent of the autocracy, S. Sharapov acted as a Polonophile, offering a sincere and honest reconciliation with Poland. His epistolary heritage, considered in this article, deserves attention as a concentrated refl ection of the Slavic problem and ways of solving it, taking into account, first of all, the interests of Russia.

Keywords: Slavophilism, Polish question, Russia, Sharapov, Borzenko.


Author(s) citation:

Cite:
Shyp Nadiia Andriivna (2018). Slavophil project for solving the "Polish question" in the Russian Empire (early 20th century). Manuscript and book heritage of Ukraine, (22) 331-357. (In Ukrainan). doi: https://doi.org/10.15407/rksu.22.331

References:

  1. Matveev, V. I. (2011). K voprosu ob etnoreligioznoi sobornosti slavianskogo mira: modeli i puti integratcii [On the issue of ethno-religious conciliarity of a Slavic world: models and ways of integration]. In Pravoslavia – tsyvilizatsiinyi stryzhen slovianskoho svitu: zbirnyk naukovykh prats [Orthodoxy as a civilization core of a Slavic world: collection of scientific works]. Kyiv: Feniks. [In Russian].
  2. Bielokolos, O. Panslavizm sohodni – instrument rosiiskoho vplyvu v Ukraini, chy ideolohiia prykryttia? [Panslavism today as an instrument of the Russian infl uence in Ukraine, or an ideology of covering?]. URL: https//www.mfaua.org/uk/publications/panslavizm-sohodni-instrument-rosiiskoho-vpluvu-v-ukraini-chy-ideolohiia-prikryttia. [In Ukrainian].
  3. Khevrolina, V. M. (1999). Vlast i obshchestvo. Borba v Rossii po voprosam vneshnei politiki. 1878–1894 [Government and society. Struggle in Russia on the issues of foreign policy. 1878–1894]. Moscow: Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences. [In Russian].
  4. Masarik, T. G. (2000). Rossiia i Evropa [Russia and Europe]. Saint Petersburg: Russian Christian Humanitarian Academy. [In Russian].
  5. Platonov, O. On videl pobedu slavianofi lov. K 150-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia Sergeia Sharapova [He saw the victory of Slavophiles. On the 150th anniversary from the day of birth of Sergei Sharapov]. URL: www/rv.ru/content.php/3?id=5909. [In Russian].
  6. Chicherin, B. (1899). Polskii i evreiskii voprosy. Otvet na otkrytye pisma N. K. Rennenkampfa [Polish and Jewish issues. Answer on open letters of N. K. Rennenkampf]. Berlin. [In Russian].
  7. Chicherin, B. (1899). Polskii i evreiskii voprosy. Otvet na otkrytye pisma N. K. Rennenkampfa [Polish and Jewish issues. Answer on open letters of N. K. Rennenkampf]. Berlin. [In Russian].
  8. Chicherin, B. (1899). Polskii i evreiskii voprosy. Otvet na otkrytye pisma N. K. Rennenkampfa [Polish and Jewish issues. Answer on open letters of N. K. Rennenkampf]. Berlin. [In Russian].
  9. Chicherin, B. (1899). Polskii i evreiskii voprosy. Otvet na otkrytye pisma N. K. Rennenkampfa [Polish and Jewish issues. Answer on open letters of N. K. Rennenkampf]. Berlin. [In Russian].
  10. Nenasheva, Z. (2006). Bratia slaviane. Rastcvet i uviadanie neoslavizma [The Slav Brothers: blooming and withering of Neo-Slavism]. In Rodina. Slavianskyi mir: obshchnost i mnogoobrazie [Motherland. Slavic world: unity and diversity], No. 4, pp. 60–63. [In Russian].
  11. Nenasheva, Z. (2006). Bratia slaviane. Rastcvet i uviadanie neoslavizma [The Slav Brothers: blooming and withering of Neo-Slavism]. In Rodina. Slavianskyi mir: obshchnost i mnogoobrazie [Motherland. Slavic world: unity and diversity], No. 4, pp. 60–63. [In Russian].
  12. Neoslavizm [Neo-Slavism]. URL: https://w.histrf.ru/articles/article/show/nieoslavizm. [In Russian].
  13. Platonov, O. On videl pobedu slavianofi lov. K 150-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia Sergeia Sharapova [He saw the victory of Slavophiles. On the 150th anniversary from the day of birth of Sergei Sharapov. URL: www.rv.ru/content.php3?id=5909. [In Russian].
  14. Platonov, O. On videl pobedu slavianofi lov. K 150-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia Sergeia Sharapova [He saw the victory of Slavophiles. On the 150th anniversary from the day of birth of Sergei Sharapov. URL: www.rv.ru/content.php3?id=5909. [In Russian].
  15. Sharapov, S. (1905). Opyt russkoi politicheskoi programmy [The experience of the Russian political program]. I. I. Mashistov Society of Typo-Lithography. [In Russian].
  16. Sharapov, S. (1905). Opyt russkoi politicheskoi programmy [The experience of the Russian political program]. I. I. Mashistov Society of Typo-Lithography. [In Russian].
  17. Sharapov, S. (1905). Opyt russkoi politicheskoi programmy [The experience of the Russian political program]. I. I. Mashistov Society of Typo-Lithography. [In Russian].
  18. Mechty i realii Rossii v tvorchestve S. F. Sharapova [Dreams and realities of Russia in the work of S. F. Sharapov]. URL:www.pravaya.ru/idea/20/6280. [In Russian].
  19. Paveleva, T. Iu. Polskaia fraktcyia v Gosudarstvennoi dume 1906–1914 godov [Polish faction in the State Duma in 1906–1914]. URL: https://tsarpolskiy.livjournal.com/9413.html. [In Russian].
  20. Sharapov, S. (1907). O polskoi avtonomii. Otkrytoe pismo k g. Romanu Dmovskomu, prezidentu Polskogo Kola vo 2-i Gosudarstvennoi Dume [On the Polish autonomy. Open letter to Mr. Roman Dmovsky, the president of the Polish Circle in the 2nd State Duma]. Moscow: I. I. Mashistov Society of Typo-Lithography. [In Russian].
  21. Sharapov, S. (1907). O polskoi avtonomii. Otkrytoe pismo k g. Romanu Dmovskomu, prezidentu Polskogo Kola vo 2-i Gosudarstvennoi Dume [On the Polish autonomy. Open letter to Mr. Roman Dmovsky, the president of the Polish Circle in the 2nd State Duma]. Moscow: I. I. Mashistov Society of Typo-Lithography. [In Russian].
  22. Egorov, S. (2001). Nauchnoe i obshchestvennoe sluzhenie tcivilista Borzenko [Scientific and public service of civilian Borzenko]. In Zakonnost [Lawfulness], No. 3, pp. 54–56. [In Russian].
  23. Nenasheva, Z. (2006). Bratia slaviane. Rastcvet i uviadanie neoslavizma [The Slav Brothers: blooming and withering of Neo-Slavism]. In Rodina. Slavianskyi mir: obshchnost i mnogoobrazie [Motherland. Slavic world: unity and diversity], No. 4 pp. 60–63. [In Russian].
  24. Pismo ministra vnutrennikh del Stolypyna Borzenko Aleksandru Aleksandrovichu po povodu sezda slavian v Rossii [Letter of Internal Affairs Minister Stolypin to Borzenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich on the congress of Slavs in Russia]. (June 30, 1907). Fund 5, Unit 2119. Institute of Manuscript of Vernadsky National Library of Ukraine. [In Russian].
  25. [Proekt Rady Vseslavianskoi i sozyva deiatelei vseslavianskikh] [The project of the All-Slav Rada and the Congress of All-Slav activists]. (20th ct.). Fund 5, Unit 804. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  26. [Proekt Rady Vseslavianskoi i sozyva deiatelei vseslavianskikh] [The project of the All-Slav Rada and the Congress of All-Slav activists]. (20th ct.). Fund 5, Unit 804. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  27. [Proekt Rady Vseslavianskoi i sozyva deiatelei vseslavianskikh] [The project of the All-Slav Rada and the Congress of All-Slav activists]. (20th ct.). Fund 5, Unit 804. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  28. [Proekt Rady Vseslavianskoi i sozyva deiatelei vseslavianskikh] [The project of the All-Slav Rada and the Congress of All-Slav activists]. (20th ct.). Fund 5, Unit 804. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  29. [Pismo prezidiuma soveshchaniia deputatov venskogo parlamenta Borzenko Aleksandru Aleksandrovichu po povodu slavianskikh sezdov] [The letter of the Presidium of the meeting of Vienna parliament members to Borzenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich on congresses of Slavs]. (November 15, 1907). Vienna. Fund 5, Unit 2120. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  30. [Pismo prezidiuma soveshchaniia deputatov venskogo parlamenta Borzenko Aleksandru Aleksandrovichu po povodu slavianskikh sezdov] [The letter of the Presidium of the meeting of Vienna parliament members to Borzenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich on congresses of Slavs]. (November 15, 1907). Vienna. Fund 5, Unit 2120. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  31. [Pismo prezidiuma soveshchaniia deputatov venskogo parlamenta Borzenko Aleksandru Aleksandrovichu po povodu slavianskikh sezdov] [The letter of the Presidium of the meeting of Vienna parliament members to Borzenko Aleksandr Aleksandrovich on congresses of Slavs]. (November 15, 1907). Vienna. Fund 5, Unit 2120. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  32. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskogo voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2122. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  33. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskogo voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2122. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  34. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskogo voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2122. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  35. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskogo voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2122. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  36. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskogo voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2122. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  37. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  38. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  39. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  40. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  41. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  42. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  43. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2123. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  44. [Pisma redaktora gazety “Russkoe delo” Borzenko A. A. po povodu slavianskoho voprosa] [Letters of Russian Affair newspaper editor to Borzenko A. A. on the Slavic issue]. (December 28, 1908 – March 2, 1908). Odesa, Smolensk. Fund 5, Unit 2124. Institute of Manuscript of VNLU. [In Russian].
  45. Nenasheva, Z. (2006). Bratia slaviane. Rastcvet i uviadanie neoslavizma [The Slav Brothers: blooming and withering of Neo-Slavism]. In Rodina. Slavianskyi mir: obshchnost i mnogoobrazie [Motherland. Slavic world: unity and diversity], No. 4, pp. 60–63. [In Russian]; Vseslavianskii sezd v Prage [All-Slav congress in Prague]. [In Russian].
  46. Neoslavizm [Neo-Slavism]. URL: https://w.histrf.ru/articles/article/show/nieoslavizm. [In Russian].
  47. Slavianskii sezd v Sofii 1910 goda [Slavic congress in Sophia in 1910]. [In Russian].
  48. Platonov, O. A. (Comp., Ed.-in-Chief). (2017). Vsemirnaia zadacha slavianstva: trudy iubileinogo vseslavianskogo sezda 26 maia – 3 iiunia 2017 g. [World task of the Slavs: works of the jubilee All-Slavic congress, May 2 – June 3, 2017]. Moscow: Russian Civilization. [In Russian].